India should shrug off DRS issue & celebrate Test win

Steven Smith's attempt to seek help from his dressing room regarding DRS, has sparked a new row, with Indian captain Virat Kohli certainly not amused.

Joy Chakravarty
by Joy Chakravarty
8th March 2017

article:8th March 2017

Team India celebrate the fall of Steven Smith's wicket on Day 4.
Team India celebrate the fall of Steven Smith's wicket on Day 4.

A series involving India and Australia has never been short on drama, entertainment and controversy, and what happened yesterday between Virat Kohli and Steven Smith at the M Chinnaswamy Stadium in Bangalore was just another new chapter added to what is already a very thick book.

Batting in the second innings yesterday, Smith was trapped leg before wicket by Umesh Yadav. The batsman walked up to the non-striker Peter Handscomb to get his opinion.

The two discussed something and Smith then looked towards the dressing room with an upward nod of his head, clearly asking the question whether he should ask for the Decision Review System (DRS) or not.

Now, the ICC rules on seeking DRS categorically state that the only consultation a batsman can have is with the non-striker.

The official Rules state: “If the umpires believe that the captain or batsman has received direct or indirect input emanating other than from the players on the field, then they may, at their discretion, decline the request for a Player Review. In particular, signals from the dressing room must not be given.”

What Smith did was definitely against the spirit of cricket, which purists will vouch for, is a lot more serious offence than misdemeanors like excessive appealing and sledging.

However, if Kohli was trying to imply his Australian counterpart is a cheat, then that won’t be correct either.

Without trying to question Kohli’s argument that this was the third time the Indians had caught the Australians – the previous two occasions had gone unnoticed by me at least – there were at least two instances just before Smith’s, which proves the Aussie captain is not a serial offender.

Just before his own decision, Smith was at the non-striker’s end when the visitors lost David Warner and Shaun Marsh – both leg before to Ravichandran Ashwin and Yadav respectively.

In both cases, the batsmen walked to Smith to ask whether they should go for the DRS. And both times, Smith did not look up to the dressing room for help.

Smith blamed it on a “brain fade”, and let’s leave it at that for the time being, and instead celebrate one of the greatest victories in recent times for India.

What seemed downright impossible after the first day, when they were bowled out for 189, became a possibility when Indian bowlers restricted Australia to 237-6 and eventually to 276 all out on day three.

That really was the most crucial phase of the match because the visitors needed to score big in their first innings, considering their second innings would be the fourth on a pitch that was causing immense problems with variable bounce.

Despite the collapse Tuesday, when the last six wickets fell for 26 runs and threatened to undo all the good work of Cheteshwar Pujara and Ajinkya Rahane, the Indian bowling and fielding rose to the occasion and sealed a memorable win.

It was almost like that famous win in Kolkata way back in 2001 when Rahul Dravid and VVS Laxman put together a 376-run partnership after India were asked to follow on.

The all-conquering Australian team under Steve Waugh, which had won the first Test in Mumbai, lost the second Test and never recovered from the shock.

They then lost the third and final Test in Chennai to lose the series 2-1. What happened in Bangalore yesterday could well spell out a 3-1 series win for the hosts.



We Recommend

Related Tags

Related Stories