Is it time for England to move on from Cook and Anderson?

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
Experienced duo: Cook and Anderson have endured tough series.

In our Monday debate, Sport360 duo Alex Broun and Chris Bailey discuss the long-term futures of experienced England duo Alastair Cook and James Anderson following the Three Lions’ disastrous Ashes campaign down under.

Should both Cook and Anderson retire from international cricket or just be moved aside?

ALEX BROUN SAYS YES, THEY SHOULD BE MOVED ON

Alastair Cook’s demise has been sad to see in this Ashes series. England’s greatest-ever Test run scorer has been a shadow of his former glory as he has limped to 83 runs in six innings at a paltry average of 13.83.

Before the series began, the question mark around England was whether Cook and captain Joe Root could provide enough cover for rookies Mark Stoneman, James Vince and Dawid Malan, but it has been the opposite with all three of the new bats performing well beyond the former captain.

But Cook’s malaise is not a new one. The one-time run machine has scored just one century and passed 50 only three times in his past 27 innings. For the first time in his career he has gone 10 knocks without a half-century, though six Tests ago he did rack up 243 against the West Indies.

If it was any other batsman, their place in the team would be under serious threat, and so it must be with Cook. It’s not just that he’s not scoring runs, he doesn’t look like scoring runs. He’s tentative, on edge, pushing and prodding, giving the close fieldsman catching practice. With a player so devoid of confidence and form, it’s doubtful he’ll ever regain his former stature. And with the Ashes surrendered, England’s selectors need to do the smart thing and use the final two Tests to try out a new opening combination. There is no point prolonging Cook’s agony.

Similarly, the once great Jimmy Anderson looks tired and pounding it on the hard Aussie pitches is doing his 35-year-old body no good.

Although he continues to give 100 per cent, he is clearly fatigued and seems one spell away from serious injury. With Craig Overton showing his potential it’s time to give Anderson his long service leave, with Chris Woakes and Stuart Broad, along with Overton, to carry the burden for the rest of the tour.

Cook and Anderson are legends of English cricket who are in danger of tarnishing proud records with inglorious exits. The selectors should save them that ignominy.

England's Alastair Cook leaves the ground after he was dismissed on day four of the third Ashes cricket Test match between Australia and England in Perth on December 17, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / Greg Wood / IMAGE RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE - STRICTLY NO COMMERCIAL USE (Photo credit should read GREG WOOD/AFP/Getty Images)

Out of form: Cook.

CHRIS BAILEY SAYS NO, ENGLAND SHOULD STICK WITH EXPERIENCE

England have been combing the British Isles for a suitable opening partner for Alastair Cook long enough to know how painful the process is. Cook, though long past his pomp, should at least be given another summer before the axe falls. Since Andrew Strauss retired in 2012, 11 opening batsmen have failed and only now, in a sturdy Mark Stoneman, have England found someone of merit. Rumours abound that Cook has been thinking long and hard about retiring to his family farm but England need him to milk a little more out of his career first.

The cupboard, to be frank, is bare. Keaton Jennings has scored 89 and 80 while touring with the England Lions Down Under this winter, but they will not be desperate to return to someone who looked so out of his depth against South Africa on home wickets.

Surrey captain Rory Burns, Middlesex’s Nick Gubbins and Cook’s Essex team-mate Nick Browne – ironically all left-handers – are young, promising, but have not yet pulled up the type of trees that would give an attack like Australia’s a root and branch examination. Poor young Haseeb Hameed scratched around for form all of last season.

It means that Cook needs to hang around to give the ECB a chance to nurture a clutch of potential successors. His mammoth knock of 243, albeit against the West Indies, is a recent reminder that all is not lost.

As for Jimmy Anderson – there is no case to answer. You’d be hard pressed to find a 35-year-old in better nick and he should not be blamed for years of negligence.

England have placed little value on sheer pace and, time and time again, shortcomings get exposed in Australia.

Pure fast bowling was never Anderson’s bag. There has arguably been no better technician of swing and the summer just gone – in which he snared 39 wickets from seven Tests – ranks up there with his best.

Don’t blame the older generation. It’s what’s coming up behind them that should alarm England fans the most.

PERTH, AUSTRALIA - DECEMBER 17: James Anderson of England bowls during day four of the Third Test match during the 2017/18 Ashes Series between Australia and England at WACA on December 17, 2017 in Perth, Australia. (Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

Anderson has struggled in Australia conditions.

Most popular

Joe Root struggles and four other reasons for England's Ashes defeat

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

England’s hopes of hanging on to the Ashes urn Down Under have disappeared after Australia took a decisive 3-0 series lead on day five in Perth.

The tourists were spared 28 of the scheduled 98 overs on the final day of the third Test but had to contend with the mental – and potentially physical – consequences of a pitch left with soft patches around the worn cracks at the Lillee-Marsh end.

They were unable to keep Josh Hazlewood (five for 48) at bay as they folded from 132 for four to 218 all out in under 35 overs to lose by an innings and 41 runs, with a session unused, and hand Australia an unassailable 3-0 series lead.

Here, Press Association Sport considers how and why the defence has evaporated with two Tests still to play.

Discipline

The moment Ben Stokes was arrested over a late-night incident in Bristol the entire tenor of the Ashes shifted.

Stokes was more than England’s vice-captain, more than their fourth seamer and more than than their most effective counter-attacking batsman.

He was the side’s heart and soul and the pivot around which the rest of the side balanced.

The precise details are yet to be established by police but at the least he fell short of the highest professional standards in the midst of an international series against the West Indies.

Jonny Bairstow took a loose view of the management’s subsequent warnings over behaviour when he bizarrely, but apparently playfully, greeted Australia opener Cameron Bancroft with a bar-room headbutt.

By the time Lions batsman Ben Duckett poured a drink on Jimmy Anderson’s head in the same Perth bar, the tour was more derailed off the pitch than on it.

Jonny Bairstow came under fire for headbutting Australia opener Cameron Bancroft.

Jonny Bairstow came under fire for headbutting Australia opener Cameron Bancroft.

Cut to the quick

England proved in 2010-11 that a raw pace barrage was not essential to victory in Australia, but the greater weight of evidence suggests it is certainly pretty handy.

Australia’s seamers are uniformly quicker than their counterparts, with others waiting in the wings, and in the absence of sustained movement through the air the touring attack has looked pedestrian and repetitive.

James Anderson and Stuart Board are champion bowlers but have not threatened the top order consistently, while it is hard to imagine a youngster of Craig Overton’s physical dimensions being allowed to settle for 80mph nibblers were he taught in Sydney rather than Somerset.

Craig Overton.

Craig Overton.

Root cause

A successful tour for England always required a major showing from their captain, Joe Root.

Widely accepted as the class act in a hastily-assembled top six, he has mustered just 176 runs in six innings.

His opposite number and peer on most pundits’ ‘best in the world’ lists, Steve Smith, topped that in a single knock at the WACA.

While Smith has been imperious and immovable, Root is beginning to face questions about whether the captaincy of a side in transition is too much to place on his shoulders.

Draining spells in the field cannot have helped him at the crease and his failures have fuelled the Australian surge.

Root scored just 176 runs in six innings.

Root scored just 176 runs in six innings.

Moeen missing in action

Moeen Ali was England’s go-to man in the domestic summer, a match-winning presence in the lower order and an increasingly reliable attacking spinner against South Africa and the West Indies.

What Root would have given to harness some of that in Brisbane and beyond.

A side strain and a cut spinning finger saw him struggle for meaningful practice before the series and he has never really found his feet since.

Unable to match Nathan Lyon for threat or control, his bowling has hit a nadir, while he is yet to add any meaningful runs.

Moeen Ali.

Moeen Ali.

Missing piece

As well as being short on express pace, England’s bowling attack boarded the plane without a full-time bowling coach.

To make up for their lower speeds, flawless planning and the ability to adapt on the hoof would have been key.

Instead, their long-standing pace mentor Ottis Gibson left to take charge of South Africa and his replacement, Chris Silverwood, is not due to start until the new year.

Filling the gap, for the first two Tests at least, was former New Zealand quick Shane Bond.

He did not know his charges well enough to present a ready-made game plan, did not boast a stellar personal record in Australia and was gone after Adelaide, with Paul Collingwood effectively adding the burden to his existing duties.

When the tale is told of this tour, this will look a costly oversight.

Chris Silverwood is not due to take charge of England's bowling department until the New Year.

Chris Silverwood (L) is not due to take charge of England’s bowling department until the new year.

Most popular

Australia regain Ashes with innings victory over England in third Test

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

England have lost the Ashes before Christmas despite Dawid Malan’s late, lone-hand resilience and a controversial three-hour delay after overnight rain got underneath the WACA’s leaky covers.

The tourists were spared 28 of the scheduled 98 overs on the final day of the third Test but had to contend with the mental – and potentially physical – consequences of a pitch left with soft patches around the worn cracks at the Lillee-Marsh end.

They were unable to keep Josh Hazlewood (five for 48) at bay as they folded from 132 for four to 218 all out in under 35 overs to lose by an innings and 41 runs, with a session unused, and hand Australia an unassailable 3-0 series lead.

Malan’s 54 held the hosts up for 135 balls, but even the best efforts of England’s sterling first-innings centurion could only delay the inevitable.

There were farcical scenes at times before play got under way as captain and coach on either side gave differing mid-pitch opinions to the umpires, with attempts to remedy the effects of rain having somehow seeped under the covers the previous evening hampered by more showers blowing across the ground.

England coach Trevor Bayliss voiced his concerns to broadcasters, during morning deliberations, that conditions had been rendered too “difficult … maybe even a little dangerous”.

Repeatedly, groundstaff and their covers were blown across the square as one squally shower after another surged in from the south-west – and a soggy hessian rug was relaid on the pitch each time, before leaf-blowers of increasing size were commandeered to aid the drying process.

Umpires Chris Gaffaney and Marais Erasmus finally decided play could get under way after an early lunch at 1pm – and, within a handful of deliveries, it was clear England were going to be up against it.

Jonny Bairstow departed to the first he faced, Hazlewood instantly locating the problem area and finding enough deviation and low bounce to utterly defeat the Yorkshireman’s tentative forward-defensive and knock back his off-stump.

Three balls later, new batsman Moeen Ali survived on four only after third umpire Aleem Dar concurred with the soft signal on the pitch that an edge to Steve Smith at second slip had not quite carried.

The Australia captain did not appear amused, but must have been heartened again in Hazlewood’s next over with another delivery to Malan that hit a crack and looped off at an angle of a metre or more into the hands of slip.

Moeen has had a poor tour, and did nothing to improve his or England’s fortunes.

He narrowly escaped his early edge off Hazlewood, then would have run himself out chancing a dodgy single if David Warner had managed a direct hit from cover.

It made little difference, because he was then lbw on the forward-defence to Nathan Lyon – falling to his opposite number for the fifth time in six innings this winter.

There was still distant hope for England while Malan held firm.

But, after he was seventh out gloving an attempted pull behind off Hazlewood, there was only the tail left, and it was soon waving goodbye to the urn.

Most popular

Related Sections