With Chelsea closing in on Alvaro Morata after Manchester United sign Romelu Lukaku, who's getting the better end of the deal?

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

Chelsea are closing in on signing Alvaro Morata, which would bring to an end one of the stranger transfer sagas of this summer that saw the Blues duel with Manchester United for Morata and Romelu Lukaku.

Oddly, each club seems to have landed the other’s No. 1 target, with Lukaku seemingly being set to go to Chelsea earlier in the summer as United chased Morata.

But which club is getting the better striker? Here’s a look at how Lukaku and Morata stack up head-to-head.

GOALSCORING

While modern strikers are expected to do more than just score, ultimately the goals are what count.

On that score, Morata had the edge on Lukaku last season – his stats per 90 minutes are much better than the Belgian’s even though he started in fewer games.

However, over the last three seasons, Lukaku has out-performed Morata, scoring 0.51 goals per 90 minutes compared to the Spaniard’s 0.33.

And even last year, Lukaku proved to be the more fearsome presence in the box, converting 30% of his shots from inside the area compared to Morata’s 27.08%. The Belgian could still lay claim to being the better poacher.

Edge: Even

LINK-UP PLAY

While Morata has the reputation for being better at holding up play and getting his teammates involved, Lukaku actually created more chances per 90 minutes last season than his counterpart, and leads in this metric over the last three seasons as well (1.30 to over 1.03). He also has completed more passes in the final third over the last three seasons (10.04 to 6.96).

Similarly, while most would assume Lukaku is the more physical player and thus the better target man, Morata won more of his aerial duels last season and draws more fouls. Morata is thus arguably a better player with his back to goal. But is Lukaku the better playmaker overall?

Edge: Lukaku

DEFENSIVE WORK RATE

Both Manchester United manager Jose Mourinho and Chelsea manager Antonio Conte require their attacking players to be fully committed to the team cause defensively, and those expectations will be laid upon Lukaku and Morata at their new clubs as well.

Lukaku has more experience playing in a defensive set-up as Everton have often played that way against the sides above them, although Morata had to do his fair share of defensive work when at Juventus.

And the stats show that even last season, when Morata was at Madrid, he bettered his counterpart when it came to tackling and interceptions, although Lukaku had more blocks per 90 minutes.

Edge: Morata

BIG-GAME PLAY

Morata has more goals in the Champions League than Diego Costa, among others, including a goal in the 2015 semi-final and final. Last season, only Lionel Messi and Neymar had more goals in the last 10 minutes of games.

Lukaku has repeatedly faced criticism for shrinking in big moments. The Belgian hasn’t played in the Champions League yet, and has a poor record in games against the so-called bigger Premier League clubs. He did, however, lead the league last season with goals in the last 10 minutes.

The closest to a head-to-head comparison between the two is their record at Euro 2016, where Morata scored three goals in four games to Lukaku’s two in four.

Edge: Morata

* All stats via Squawka

Most popular

Related Sections

Ryan Giggs expects Manchester United to keep promoting youth, hopeful of another 'Class of 92' at Old Trafford

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
Ryan Giggs

Former Manchester United winger Ryan Giggs expects his old club to continue their tradition of promoting youth and is hopeful another ‘Class of 92’ can emerge at Old Trafford.

Press Association Sport has conducted a study which found 10 of the players who featured for United in the Premier League last season graduated from their own academy, with Jose Mourinho’s side using more of their own academy players than any other top-flight outfit.

That figure includes Paul Pogba, who returned to United from Juventus in a world-record £89million move last summer, Marcus Rashford and Angel Gomes, the 16-year-old who in May became the first player born in this millennium to feature in the Premier League.

United’s philosophy of handing opportunities to youngsters dates back to the Busby Babes of the 1950s, while the ‘Class of 92’ of Giggs, David Beckham, Paul Scholes, Nicky Butt and the Neville brothers formed the core for their success four decades later.

Giggs believes it is increasingly more challenging for clubs to nurture kids through their ranks until they break through into the first team like he did, but he does not see the conveyor belt stopping.

“Generally, you get a chance in the first team (at United) which no other big clubs predominantly give you,” he told Press Association Sport.

“It’s getting harder because of the money (Manchester) City, Chelsea, all the big clubs are willing to pay, which in my day didn’t happen as much.

“You have teams offering all sorts to 14, 15-year-olds. It’s very difficult for parents now to decide which team to go to and it might not be football reasons first but financial stability. But I think United will always produce young players.”

They brought through a glut of talent at once at the start of the 1990s when Giggs and co emerged together and formed the nucleus of a team which achieved great success under Sir Alex Ferguson.

Giggs, promoting the People’s Award for the 2017 McDonald’s Community Awards, would love to see another raft of graduates break through in similar fashion and insists it can happen at Old Trafford, even if the Premier League’s current landscape makes it harder.

“It’s a big ask – five or six players coming through and staying in the team for so long was extraordinary,” he said.

“It probably comes along once every generation but if you have the philosophy within the club to bring young players through I don’t see why three or four players can’t come through and stay in the team.

“That’s the key – not just coming through, but actually staying in the team. It’s getting more and more difficult because managers don’t get much time – they are not able to let them make their mistakes – for them to grow, but I hope it happens.”

Giggs highlighted Tottenham’s Harry Kane and United’s own forward Rashford as two examples of why he believes supporters still cherish witnessing the growth of an academy product over a big-money acquisition.

“You see the emergence of Harry Kane and his song at Tottenham is, ‘He’s one of our own’,” Giggs said.

“Fans can relate to players that they’ve seen in the youth team, then the reserves. At my club there’s Rashford and there’s excitement and pride within Old Trafford when he gets the ball and makes something happen.

“It’s different from a player who has signed for a lot of money because there is an affinity with a player who has been there, like Marcus, since he was eight or nine.”

* Provided by Press Association Sport

Most popular

Related Sections

Signing Romelu Lukaku signals Man United's title intent, says Vincent Kompany

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

Vincent Kompany believes Manchester United’s signing of fellow Belgian Romelu Lukaku shows how intense the competition will be for this year’s Premier League title.

“More teams than ever not just can but have to claim that they want to be Premier League champions,” Kompany said. “Everybody is investing heavily at the moment.”

The Manchester City captain praised his compatriot, saying Lukaku’s hunger to score goals is what sets him apart.

“A lot of people have commented on Romelu over the years and he’s taken a lot of criticism, but his biggest strength is his belief in himself and his ability to score goals.”

Here more from Kompany in the video below.

Most popular

Related Tags

Related Sections