It has been almost 14 years since Dinesh Karthik made his debut for India at the iconic Lords in an ODI against England. Since then, he has been in and out of the side, never truly establishing himself, before his career’ biggest moment arrived in Colombo with a last-ball six against Bangladesh to win the Nidahas Trophy for India.
Calm and composed under intense pressure, the 32-year-old wicket-keeper batsman smashed an eight-ball 29 to clinch victory when the match was all but lost with 34 needed from two overs. His cameo, which he himself described as a ‘memory of lifetime’, has resulted in calls to instate Karthik as the wicket-keeper in the limited-overs side in the run-up to the 2019 ICC World Cup.
Those calls may be a little far-fetched since MS Dhoni remains the best wicketkeeper-batsman in white ball cricket. It has been Karthik’s misfortune that his career has coincided with that of Dhoni, who made his debut for India in 2004 as well.
He has lived in the shadow of Dhoni for so long, youngsters like Rishab Pant are being seen as Dhoni’s replacement as and when that time comes. However, with his whirlwind knock in Colombo, Karthik has sent a timely reminder to selectors about his match-winning abilities.
The Tamil Nadu man became the forgotten man of Indian cricket after 2014, before a prolific run in domestic cricket gave Karthik some opportunities for India last year. Even so, he has not been given a consistent run in the side.
Still, the right-handed batsman does what is expected of him time and again. In the absence of regular stars in the Nidahas Cup, Karthik was the experienced member of the side. He played that role to perfection, remaining unbeaten in all five innings.
And it is in this role that Karthik could become a crucial player for India as they prepare the squad for next year’s World Cup. While the possibility of Karthik taking the gloves from Dhoni is remote, he could very well play purely as a batsman capable of hitting the big shots in the death overs.
Dhoni’s impact with the bat is not what it used to be, with the veteran now more comfortable rotating the strike in the middle order. Karthik has it in him to be the number six batsman India are looking for, especially since the likes of Manish Pandey and Kedar Jadhav have failed to deliver.
He might not replace Dhoni as India wicket-keeper but he is definitely a worthy alternative. And with his finishing abilities, Karthik can fill a huge hgap in India’s lower order.
After remaining on the fringes of Indian cricket for much of his international career, this might just be Karthik’s time.
As South Africa celebrated the high of a Test win against Australia to level the series at Port Elizabeth on Monday, the ICC delivered a jolt. Pace spearhead Kagiso Rabada was handed a two-Test suspension for inappropriate conduct by the ICC hours after victory, effectively ruling him out of the remainder of the series.
The warning signs were there for Rabada before the start of the Test.
The 22-year-old pacer, exceptionally talented as he is, has a history of disciplinary issues. Since making his Test debut in 2015, the fast-bowler’s indiscretions have landed him in trouble.
The South African has now been charged five times by the ICC for various offences following his twin run-ins in the Port Elizabeth Test. His first breach came after an altercation with Sri Lanka’s Niroshan Dickwella during an ODI at Cape Town last year.
Both players were docked 50 per cent of their match fees along with three ICC demerit points for their conduct. Four demerit points equals a one-Test or two ODIs/T20s, whichever comes first.
Hence, when South Africa toured England three months later, the pacer was walking a tight-rope disciplinary wise. During the second Test at Trent Bridge, he gave Ben Stokes an expletive laden send-off after dismissing him. Rabada was subsequently given a demerit point for his behaviour, resulting in a one-Test suspension.
The pace did not learn his lesson. He repeated the same offence, this time against India’s Shikhar Dhawan in an ODI series last month. Another demerit point followed and meant that the youngster came into the Australia series with five of them to his name, putting him on the verge of a two-Test suspension.
The David Warner-Quinton de Kock shenanigans left a sour taste in the mouths of both camps and emotions were high. Before the start of the second Test, Proteas veteran Dale Steyn inferred that Rabada had been bowling on a ‘leash’ due to his disciplinary issues and that it was unfair as the Aussies were supposedly going about their business as usual.
It seems the youngster took that call to heart. Even as he bowled his heart out in the second Test, Rabada’s match-winning efforts were overshadowed by two code of conduct violations. The first for making contact with Steve Smith’s shoulder in the first innings after trapping him lbw and the second for giving Warner one of his now infamous sendoffs.
Might seem like it is hard on Rabada, especially when he is in the form of his life, but when there is a system, you have to play within it.— Harsha Bhogle (@bhogleharsha) March 12, 2018
The youngster knew he had indeed crossed the line when he appeared for the post-match press conference.
“I’ve let myself and the team down,” he said.
“But I have to move forward and I have to see, if I do get banned, then I have to see it as a big learning curve and not repeat the same mistake, because I’ve repeated the same mistake in the eyes of the umpires. I’m not happy about it,” he added.
Hours later, as feared, he was suspended. After the match, there has been intense debate among current and former players on whether such punishments are stifling a format which is already struggling to get eyeballs.
But whichever way you look at it, it is Rabada’s fault that he landed in that situation. While aggression remains one of the biggest weapons of most fast bowlers, it can always be channelled in a way which does not bring about one’s own downfall. Rabada only has to look at how Steyn went about his business without ever curbing his aggression.
What is infuriating about the youngster’s troubles is the fact he has been down this road before. Repeating the same offence three times in short span is a sign of indifference and recklessness.
He might have learnt his lesson for now but it has come at a huge cost to his side. As bowler who seems destined to end up as one of the greats of the game, Rabada needs to cut out the ‘celebrations’ for now.
Two years ago Rishabh Pant was one of the hottest properties in Indian cricket. His heroics in the ICC U19 World Cup for the Indian colts saw IPL outfit Delhi Daredevils fork out a whopping sum of Rupees 19 million (Dh108,000) for the young wicketkeeper-batsman during 2016.
The southpaw’s ability to clear the fence regularly with gutso and penchant is what has brought him many admirers in the Indian cricket community.
After a terrific domestic season with the bat during 2016-17 where he scored a triple-hundred against Maharashtra in the Ranji trophy and a 48-ball ton against Jharkhand, Pant was handed his maiden India cap in a T20I against England at Bengaluru.
He did not get much of a chance to showcase his ability in that match, getting to face only three deliveries for an unbeaten knock of five runs. He was however picked again for the T20s when India toured the West Indies in July last year and played a sole match in Kingston.
On that day, Pant managed to score a 35-ball 38, a far cry from the explosive tag he carried with him. It was simply a case of him trying too hard to smash every ball out of the ground. That desperation perhaps, is a by-product of his reputation of being a big and clean hitter of the ball.
It is almost as if Pant has to justify that tag whenever he puts on the Blues of India. Following the T20I against the West Indies, the Delhi-based youngster did not get any more games for the national side until the ongoing Nidahas T20 tri-series in Sri Lanka.
There too, in the opening match against the hosts, Pant flattered to deceive. With Shikhar Dhawan giving India a solid platform to launch off from in the death overs, the 20-year-old struggled to find a clean connection as he looked to launch each and every ball out of the ground.
His struggles at one end forced Dhawan to up the ante himself and the opener paid the price with his wicket. Pant on the other hand, scored a run-a-ball 23 despite collecting a six and a boundary as India lost their way a little towards the death overs.
With MS Dhoni all but confirmed to be India’s wicket-keeping option in the 2019 ICC World Cup, there is no real rush for Pant to force himself into contention. His time will come, for he has been clearly earmarked by the board as one for the future.
That is why he is being tried out in the odd T20 match here and there, so that come 2019, he is ready to take over the mantle from the veteran stalwart.
The talent is clearly there, as evidenced by his 32-ball hundred against Himachal Pradesh in January, the second-fastest T20 ton in history and the fastest by an Indian.
The question for Pant therefore is, why the hurry? Maybe it is time the youngster stopped putting so much pressure on himself to perform and let his natural talent do the talking.
His time with the Indian senior team will come. For now, he needs to start enjoying the game and the boundaries will flow again.