AFL 2017 Report Card: Richmond, Essendon, Port Adelaide impress as Hawthorn, Collingwood, Brisbane Lions, Gold Coast Suns flop

Alex Broun 09:34 04/09/2017
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • With the AFL finals series about to begin, we look over all 18 clubs to assess their chances.

    ADELAIDE CROWS

    2016: 5th (SF); 2017: 1st (+4)

    Anything but the title will be a huge disappointment, but their form has slipped with just two wins from last five.

    RATING: A

    BRISBANE LIONS

    2016: 17th; 2017: 18th (-1)

    The titles of 2001-03 are a distant memory and the AFL must be increasingly worried about the game up north.

    RATING: F

    CARLTON

    2016: 14th; 2017: 16th (-2)

    The once proud Blues look no closer to their first GF since 1999. Culture of failure is home to stay at Princes Park.

    RATING: C

    COLLINGWOOD

    2016: 12th; 2017: 13th (-1)

    Another bad season for the Pies making the decision to re-appoint Nathan Buckley even stranger. Painful for fans.

    RATING: D-

    ESSENDON

    2016: 18th; 2017: 7th (+11)

    Superb performance from the resurgent Bombers going from wooden spoon to finals in one season. WADA who?

    RATING: A+

    Jobe Watson and Dyson Heppell.

    Jobe Watson and Dyson Heppell.

    FREMANTLE

    2016: 16th; 2017: 14th (+2)

    Another depressing season for Ross Lyon’s team who seem a long way away from the glory years of 2012-15.

    RATING: C

    GWS GIANTS

    2016: 4th (PF); 2017: 4th (-)

    One kick away from the GF last year, GWS will be rueing two draws that could see them miss out again this year.

    RATING: A-

    GEELONG CATS

    2016: 2nd (PF); 2017: 2nd (-)

    So long the bench mark of the competition, the Cats will again go close. In impressive form coming in to the finals.

    RATING: A

    Patrick Dangerfield.

    Patrick Dangerfield.

    GOLD COAST SUNS

    2016: 15th; 2017: 17th (-2)

    Another poor year from the expansion club, who have the lowest supporter base in the AFL — Ablett or no Ablett.

    RATING: E

    HAWTHORN

    2016: 3rd (SF); 2017: 12th (-9)

    The mighty Hawks came down to earth with a thud in 2017 and will be interesting to see if they can bounce back.

    RATING: D

    Tom Mitchell.

    Tom Mitchell.

    MELBOURNE

    2016: 11th; 2017: 9th (+2)

    All set for finals footy for the first time since 2006 before a shock loss to the Pies in final round. Will hurt all summer.

    RATING: B-

    NORTH MELBOURNE

    2016: 8th (EF); 2017: 15th (-7)

    The over-achieveing Kangas had one to forget in 2017. The playing list isn’t great and may not be back for awhile.

    RATING: C-

    PORT ADELAIDE

    2016: 10th; 2017: 5th (+5)

    A good year for SA with both teams in the eight for first time since 2007. What price Showdown 44 in the GF?

    RATING: A+

    RICHMOND

    2016: 13th; 2017: 3rd (+10)

    One of the biggest improvers of the year and a strong chance to go all the way, No1 backline in the competition.

    RATING: A+

    Star man: Dustin Martin.

    Star man: Dustin Martin.

    ST KILDA

    2016: 9th; 2017: 11th (-2)

    Hopeful of playing finals footy for the first time since 2011 but faded badly. Recriminations go on at Moorabbin.

    RATING: B

    SYDNEY SWANS

    2016: 1st (RU); 2017: 6th (-5)

    Felt they should have won last year and sulked for the first six games of 2017. Will back themselves to do a Dogs.

    RATING: B+

    WEST COAST EAGLES

    2016: 6th (EF); 2017: 8th (-2)

    A morale boosting win over the Crows in the last round saw them sneak into the finals, but still flag outsiders.

    RATING: B-

    WESTERN BULLDOGS

    2016: 7th (P); 2017: 10th (-3)

    Surprise premiers last year the Doggies will be disappointed they did not do a better job defending the title.

    RATING: C

    Marcus Bontempelli.

    Marcus Bontempelli.

    Recommended