Ranking all Liverpool's signings from Southampton from worst to best

Alex Broun 14:00 10/02/2018
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

Liverpool has been a regular raider of talent from Southampton in the Premier League era. No less than seven players (not counting on-loan goalkeeper Paul Jones) have made the trip north to Anfield, costing the Reds a total of 173 million pounds (Dh881.3m).

And that doesn’t include ex-Saint Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain who made his way to Liverpool via Arsenal.

So it’s no surprise that the Reds are not liked too much down south as they have regularly purloined the best the Saints have to offer.

So many Southampton players have made the switch to Liverpool that the Saints finally said enough is enough trying to hold on to Virgil van Dijk for as long as possible – before they were finally forced to release him as well.

Here’s our rankings on the worst to best Liverpool signings from Southampton:

BIRMINGHAM, ENGLAND - JANUARY 17: Rickie Lambert of Liverpool celebrates scoring their second goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Aston Villa and Liverpool at Villa Park on January 17, 2015 in Birmingham, England. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)

Rickie Lambert celebrates scoring a rare goal for Liverpool.

6. Rickie Lambert – Signed 2014 (£4m)

This was one everyone – the player, the club, the fans and the manager – wanted to work, but sadly that wasn’t the case.

Lambert came from humble beginnings, working in a beetroot factory while playing in the lower divisions for Rochdale, Bristol Rovers and Stockport County.

But his rise to England international during his time at Southampton was widely celebrated.

Even Saints fans didn’t hold it against him too much when he achieved his boyhood dream of joining the Reds from Southampton in 2014.

But the timing for Lambert was all wrong. Originally signed as a backup option for Luis Suarez and Daniel Sturridge, he came into a club still reeling from the effects of a near-miss Premier League campaign.

When Sturridge was injured Lambert was thrust into the first team and was given even more responsibility when Mario Balotelli’s signing to replace Suarez backfired superbly.

Sadly for all involved Lambert left in 2015 after scoring just three times in 36 appearances and never netting a goal at his beloved Anfield.

Ranking: Never looked at home at Liverpool. D

5. Dejan Lovren – Signed 2014 (£20m)

Lovren arrived at Liverpool in the summer of 2014 as the most expensive defender in the club’s history – a title he gave up to Van Dijk when he arrived a few years later.

But inconsistency and defensive blunders have continued to plague the 28-year-old.

His passion and commitment can never be questioned but his inexcusable errors – seen most recently in the near air-swing that gifted Harry Kane a penalty against Tottenham – have driven Liverpool fans (and his fellow players) to fits of despair.

Klopp’s arrival did see an upturn in form – as did the partnership with Joel Matip – but there have just been far too many blunders for Liverpool fans (or his fellow defenders) to trust him again.

The reality is Lovren will never be a constant member of a stable Reds back four.

Ranking: Too much uncertainty makes him a defensive liability. C

4. Adam Lallana – Signed 2014 (£25m)

Lallana has shown flashes of brilliance since his arrival before the 2014-15 season.

He struggled under Brendan Rodgers but Klopp’s arrival in October 2015 saw the England midfielder develop the consistency that was previously lacking and last season he started to justify his reputation – and price-tag.

But the injury curse continues to strike the 29-year-old and many are starting to wonder if the ex-Southampton captain’s best days are behind him.

Lallana must start to deliver – and soon.

Ranking: Flashes of brilliance but injuries becoming a real concern. B

3. Peter Crouch – Signed 2005 (£7m)

Coming a decade before the recent raids that have made Liverpool so unpopular on the south coast, the bean-pole striker, now at Stoke, was brought to Liverpool from Saints as Rafa Benitez sought to add a little height to the European Champions forward line.

The two metre frontman struggled to adapt to life at Anfield and it took him 19 games before he eventually scored his first Liverpool goal against Wigan in December 2005.

Crouch soon found his feet however, and the back of the net fairly regularly, and would go on to tally 42 goals in 134 appearances.

He was part of the Liverpool side that won the FA Cup in 2006 and “Crouchy” is fondly remembered by most Reds supporters.

Ranking: Scored some important goals and still remembered well by Reds fans. B+

BIRKENHEAD, ENGLAND - JULY 12: Nathaniel Clyne of Liverpool during a pre-season friendly match between Tranmere Rovers and Liverpool at Prenton Park on July 12, 2017 in Birkenhead, England. (Photo by Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

Nathaniel Clyne has spent most of the season out injured.

2. Nathaniel Clyne – Signed 2015 (£12m)

Perhaps not the biggest name signing but the right back has been a beacon of consistency since his move in the summer of 2015.

The position was his own up until this season when injury has opened the door to his youthful competitors Trent Alexander-Arnold and Joe Gomez.

Before that Clyne had barely missed a Liverpool game – with 93 appearances already – but the England full-back has been absent all campaign with a back problem.

He underwent a corrective operation in London recently as the Reds look for a cure to the long-standing issue. Hopefully he will be back to fight for his place soon.

Ranking: A lot depends on how he comes back from long term injury – but with Gomez and Alexander-Arnold many years his junior it may be tough for him to reclaim his starting spot. A-

1. Sadio Mane – Signed 2016 (£30m)

The Senegal winger was a smash hit when he first arrived from Southampton. People knew he was good – but not this good.

Eyebrows may have been raised when the Reds raided the Saints (yet again) and spent £30m, but the dynamic frontman soon made those early fears look laughable.

He netted 13 goals before injury ended his first Reds campaign in the Merseyside derby on April 1 last year.

However, he wasted little time picking up where he left off this term, adjusting superbly to a new left-sided role in Klopp’s front three.

His form has been a little patchy of late, and he has been over-shadowed by the exceptional Mohamed Salah – but he still remains an excellent bit of business for Liverpool.

Rankings: Electrifying on his day. A+

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - JANUARY 05: Virgil van Dijk of Liverpool (2R) scores their second goal during the Emirates FA Cup Third Round match between Liverpool and Everton at Anfield on January 5, 2018 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Clive Brunskill/Getty Images)

Hopes were high after Virgil van Dijk headed the winner against Everton at Anfield – but how will his long term form develop?

Virgil van Dijk – Signed 2017 (£75m)

It was a long drawn out saga but Liverpool finally snared Van Dijk in January for a club-record fee, the Dutchman enjoyed a dream debut as he scored the winning goal to knock Everton out of the FA Cup on January 5.

His second and third appearances however were not as memorable as the Reds stumbled to a surprise loss at Swansea and then undid all their good work against Everton by being knocked out of the FA Cup by West Brom – who scored three goals in the first half at Anfield.

The 26-year-old returned to the Liverpool side that drew 2-2 with Spurs last week, and although the most expensive defender in football history had some good moments he did concede the last-gasp penalty.

Despite this he seems to have the personality and character to anchor the Reds’ defensive line for many years to come.

Rating: Too soon to judge – but much can be expected from the big Dutchman.  ?

1102 liverpool grade

Know more about Sport360 Application


Most popular