They hit the post early on but were then nowhere to be seen as Bayern were 4-0 up at the break through goals for former players Mats Hummels and Robert Lewandowski, the others coming from Javi Martinez and Serge Gnabry.
Gnabry then teed up Lewandowski to seal an embarrassing defeat at the death, leaving Lucien Favre’s side in the familiar position of looking up at their illustrious rivals from second place.
Here we rate the Dortmund players. Spoiler, it’s not pretty reading:
BORUSSIA DORTMUND (4-3-3)
Roman Burki – 8: Excellent stop from Lewandowski kept rampant Bayern at bay, then tipped over Muller’s header. Could have been a farcical scoreline were it not for several top stops from the Swiss.
Lukasz Piszczek – 4: Couldn’t climb high enough to challenge Hummels. Roasted often by Coman’s blistering pace. Led side with seven tackles. A fading force.
Manuel Akanji – 3: Hopelessly stuck hand up for offside for Gnabry’s goal when he simply failed to follow him. Out of his depth. Five clearances led BVB.
Dan-Axel Zagadou – 2: Horrendous error allowed Lewandowski an opportunity. Unforgivable. Then shown yellow for bringing down the Bayern frontman. Hooked at the break.
Abdou Diallo – 4: On the ground, brought the ball out well. In the air, looked like he believed jumping had been outlawed. Led side with three interceptions.
Mahmoud Dahoud – 4: Only scored one goal for BVB and it showed as he struck the post when he really should have scored. Overawed, match summed up when playing a through ball to Reus who was yards offside.
Axel Witsel – 5: Enjoying a fine season but marooned in a Dortmund midfield that was simply outmuscled and outmanoeuvred. Worryingly unable to exert any influence.
Thomas Delaney – 5 Alert to hook clear Coman’s low centre. Busy but struggled to contain Munich’s marauding forwards. Booked for cynical foul on Lewandowski.
Jadon Sancho – 4: Looked nervous. Switched from right to left but made little difference, and he made little impact. 66.7 per cent pass accuracy in first half improved to 75 but a tough day at the office.
Marco Reus – 5: An anonymous performance from the captain, but with Bayern relentless and Dortmund penned in from the off, was always fighting losing battle.
Jacob Bruun Larsen – 3: Linked up well with Reus to fashion Dahoud chance. But failed to track Muller in lead-up to killer third goal. Four unskilled touches. Not his best day.
Julian Weigl – 7: Replaced the hopeless Zagadou and at least tried to restore some semblance of order.
Mario Gotze – 6: Coming on against his old club 4-0 down was not ideal. One of only four Dortmund players to have a shot.
Marius Wolf – 6: Replaced exhausted Piszczek, with game well out of his side’s reach.
Dortmund have a two-point lead after scoring two injury-time goals to beat Wolfsburg last weekend while Munich unexpectedly drew with Freiburg.
Here are the talking points for the game.
DORTMUND NEED TO GO ALL OUT IN MUST-WIN GAME
Usually, for a team with a two-point lead, a draw away from home against the second-placed side would be considered a good point.
But Dortmund aren’t going to feel safe with a two-point lead over Bayern for the rest of the season. It would require perfection from the remaining six games to win the title, because they can’t rely on the Bavarians to slip up – even if, as last weekend showed, it does happen.
Lucien Favre’s side need the five-point cushion a win would give them. Even if it’s equally true that they can’t afford to lose and fall a point behind, Dortmund will be better served risking going all out for a win.
Plus, despite their recent domestic dominance, Bayern have shown they can be rattled – they survived a bizarre midweek cup game against second-tier Heidenheim in a wild 5-4 win. The Black and Yellow need to take advantage.
Niko Kovač after the Freiburg game: Not only disappointed but also angry.pic.twitter.com/oc5ia0LCcd— Bayern & Germany (@iMiaSanMia) March 31, 2019
BAYERN’S STARS NEED TO STEP UP
It wasn’t long ago that Bayern Munich faced a season-defining game and fluffed their lines. Last month, Liverpool came to Munich with the score at 0-0 going into the second leg of the Champions League round of 16 tie between the two sides. Niko Kovac’s side duly crashed out of Europe with a listless performance in a 3-1 loss.
James Rodriguez, Robert Lewandowski, Frank Ribery, Mats Hummels – all over the pitch there were big-name players shrinking on the big stage.
Dortmund aren’t quite Liverpool but they’ve already beaten Bayern this season – and that too, in a game where Munich twice took the lead. The Bavarians struggled in their Champions League group stage games against Ajax as well, failing to win on either occasion. That means in five meetings with teams close to their level in games that mattered this season, Bayern are winless. They can’t afford to make it six.
The last time we played Bayern 🔄— Borussia Dortmund (@BlackYellow) April 5, 2019
You know the rest...🇪🇸🔥 pic.twitter.com/67z3lI6fKE
ALL EYES ON JADON SANCHO
While the big-game prowess of some of Bayern’s stars may be in doubt, it’s a Dortmund star who will be the centre of attention.
Jadon Sancho has been getting praise from all corners this season, and it’s been deserved – any time a 19-year-old is in competition with the likes of Lionel Messi and Eden Hazard for most assists in the top five leagues in Europe, the hype is justified.
But apart from a goal in Dortmund’s stunning 4-0 Champions League group stage win over Atletico Madrid, Sancho hasn’t quite shown the ability to lift his performance for a game like this. He had a relatively quiet game when these two sides met back in November, and had little impact in the two games against Tottenham that sent Dortmund out of Europe.
If he delivers on Saturday the hype train will go into overdrive. But he has a few questions to answer first.
🤩🤝 Most assists in the Top 5 leagues in Europe...— The Sportsman Stats (@SportsmanStats) April 5, 2019
- Sancho: 13
- Hazard: 12
- Messi: 12
- Eriksen: 11
- Di Maria: 10 pic.twitter.com/3RXhDX5sJ2
As things stand, Dortmund are on top of the table with 63 points and Bayern are not far behind with 61. With just seven games left, it’s fair to say that the winner of Der Klassiker could possibly go on to clinch the title.
But how did the teams get to where they are? Did luck play a part in shaping the points table? We take a look at the numbers behind their seasons.
The concept of xPTS (Expected points)
The concept of xPTS is similar to xG (Expected goals) and xGA (Expected goals against). It’s a number between zero and three, which gives information on the amount of points a particular team should have won in that game based on the quality of chances created and conceded.
Data from xG and xGA can be used to simulate the game over 1000-10000 times to arrive at the decimal which corresponds to the total points the tam should have won in that game. Luckily, we were saved from writing the code as the numbers were available at understat.com.
Needless to say, a team with xPTS close to three were the better team that created better chances, conceded only a few and dominated the game on the whole.
Bundesliga teams and xPTS
The positive difference of PTS over xPTS (Actual points and expected points) can be attributed to a team being rather fortunate. A negative figure here means that the team was unlucky and deserved better.
In the graph, we have xPTS on the x-axis and PTS-xPTS on the y-axis. This means that teams which have performed well and have gotten lucky will lie in the first quadrant, with Dortmund leading the line. Teams which have performed well but have been unlucky fall in the fourth quadrant and Bayern are the leaders in this category.
To put it in numbers, Dortmund have accumulated 63 points, while their XPTS is just 51.34. This means that they have been able to garner 11.66 ‘lucky points’. Bayern, on the other hand, should have had 63.92 points, but have won just 61 points. The Bavarian club have been slightly unlucky and should probably have been table-toppers.
It’s interesting to note that RB Leipzig have an xPTS of 51.59. which is marginally greater than Dortmund’s. Statistically speaking and subtracting the ‘lucky’ points, Leipzig should have been second on the table, ahead of Dortmund.
Are Dortmund getting lucky or are they creating their own luck?
It’s easy to sit behind a computer screen and label a team which is on the verge of ending Bayern’s monopoly as ‘lucky’, right? However, Dortmund are – in a way – creating their own luck.
In the 2016/17 season, NICE finished third in Ligue 1 with 78 points. Their xPTS in that season was 53.47. This means that they earned 24 ‘lucky’ points. Who was their manager at that time? Lucien Favre. At this point, it would be prudent to attribute the vast difference to Favre’s style of play.
Dortmund have managed to win some games even when their xPTS was lower than that of their opposition’s. The most notable example of such a game was when they beat Augsburg 4-3 at home.
Dortmund’s xPTS in this game measured just 0.76, while Augsburg’s was 2.06. Dortmund had scored three goals after 75 minutes in this game. So, are Favre’s men creating their own luck at the death?
Dortmund have scored 66 goals this season at an xG of 51.29. What’s interesting is that they have scored 20 of them after 76 minutes, while the xG generated in that time period of games is just 9.86. They have scored more than twice their xG in the closing stages, which is really impressive.
In contrast, Bayern have scored just 12 goals after 76 minutes, at an xG of 14.81. It’s fair to say that Niko Kovac’s men have not made the best of their chances in the death. It’s also worth noting that Dortmund have scored 20 goals from 77 shots in the last 15 minutes of games, whereas Bayern have managed to net just 12 of the 85 shots they took.
Whether it’s lack of service to Robert Lewandowski or the Polish international’s inability to convert chances that he should, Bayern have only themselves to blame.
Ultimately, the goals in the last 15 minutes have separated the two sides. Dortmund’s clinical finishing and superior mental fortitude has allowed them to clinch games at the death.
The tale of Paco Alcacer and Robert Lewandowski
It takes consistent clinical finishing from a top player to register more goals than what his xG suggests. The presence of such a player could also account for some of the ‘lucky’ points Dortmund have accumulated.
Paco Alcacer has scored 16 goals this season at an xG of 8.93, over-performing with a difference of +7.07. Lionel Messi – of course – is the only player in Europe’s top five leagues to have a bigger difference (+9.44).
Alcacer’s profligacy in front of goal is yet another reason Dortmund find themselves where they are and where they arguably deserve to be – top of the Bundesliga table.
On the other hand, Lewandowski has managed to score just 19 goals at an xG of 27.60. Clearly, he has terribly underperformed and the difference of -8.60 sums it up.
The trend does not look good for Dortmund
This graph shows the variation of ‘lucky’ points over time for Dortmund and Bayern. While Bayern show no distinct trend, it’s clear that Dortmund’s ‘luck’ is running out. In the last two months, they have won just about as many points as their xPTS has suggested they would. It’s not surprising that it was during this period that they temporarily conceded the top spot to Bayern and slacked off.
Favre needs to ensure that this trend does not continue and Dortmund get back to creating their luck once again. This could be crucial for them in the title race.