Man United 0-1 Barcelona: Player ratings as Scott McTominay shines and strikers flop

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

Barcelona remain favourites to make the Champions League semi-finals thanks to a first-half own goal from Manchester United’s makeshift centre-back Luke Shaw.

The La Liga holders produced a measured performance at Old Trafford, restricting their opponents to zero shots on target and profiting after Uruguay striker Luis Suarez’s header flicked in off the unfortunate Shaw during the 12th minute.

Few other chances of note occurred in this 1-0 victory for visitors who did not need to be at their blistering best. The clubs meet again for the decider at Camp Nou next Tuesday.

MANCHESTER UNITED (3-5-2)

David De Gea 7: Made one trademark save with his feet from Coutinho. Otherwise, surprisingly quiet.

Victor Lindelof 6: Loose clearance led to Coutinho’s first-half opportunity. Recovered from this error.

Chris Smalling 6: Charged through Messi and left the great man blooded. Only negative was work on ball.

Luke Shaw 5: Victim of curious management. Was all at sea for his own goal. Better after break.

Ashley Young 5: Did well to keep Coutinho quiet. Yet was absolutely appalling in possession. 11 crosses, zero accurate.

Scott McTominay 7: A growing presence. Sharp in the tackle, breaking up play diligently. Passing could have been better.

Fred 7: Has made major mistakes in previous games, but added requisite energy to Solskjaer’s press. Registered 15 recoveries.

Paul Pogba 5: Distinctly did not put “stamp” on this match, despite Solskjaer request. Real Madrid beware?

Diogo Dalot 6: Did his part in making this a quiet night for Messi. But what was he doing with that header?

Romelu Lukaku 5: Gamble to play two up-top didn’t pay off. Lukaku endured a negligible impact, having 20 touches.

Marcus Rashford 5: Frustrating performance. Got into good positions, but wasted them with wild shots.

SUBSTITUTES

Anthony Martial 6: Denied by one supreme covering tackle from ex-United starlet Pique.

Jesse Lingard 5: Picked up early booking and couldn’t get into the game.

Andreas Pereira N/A: Thrown on as United settled for a 1-0 defeat.

Most popular

Revered Barcelona rivalry can spur Man United to victory in Champions League

Matt Jones 10/04/2019
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
United beat Barcelona in the semi-finals on their way to a second Champions League crown in 2008.

There won’t be many neutrals or even partisan fans who would give Manchester United a hope of reaching the Champions League semi-finals – but the previous round is a good indicator of what drama football is capable of conjuring.

Their rich history with quarter-final opponents Barcelona can also serve as a motivating factor for the Red Devils as they look to finish the season with silverware – however remote the possibility – as well as reboot the resurgence overseen by Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.

The 3-1 win in Paris to haul United into the last eight was undoubtedly the best result of Solskjaer’s reign so far, and went some way in securing the manager’s job on a full-time basis.

But rather than serve as a continuing catalyst for the change implemented under the Norwegian – seen as not very strong tactically when he first was put in interim charge at Old Trafford – it feels a little like United peaked in Paris.

Since that epic result against Paris Saint-Germain, United have slipped to three defeats in their following four games. Their sole win was a scrappy and barely deserved 2-1 home triumph against FA Cup finalists Watford.

A pair of defeats to Wolves, meanwhile, has seen them lose ground in the race for the Premier League’s top four – defeat to Arsenal also hindered their progress – and exit the FA Cup quarter-finals, a competition that was their best hope for ending the season with a trophy.

Paul Scholes scored the only goal when the two sides met in the last eight of the 2008 tournament.

Paul Scholes scored the only goal when the two sides met in the last eight of the 2008 tournament.

Paul Pogba’s loss of form is a concern, while Solskjaer is without Nemanja Matic and Ander Herrera – two of his most important and resurgent players in recent months – for the visit of Barcelona. Herrera’s future is also up for discussion and a worrisome run of results has contributed to a feeling of unease around Old Trafford.

However, United have risen to the occasion consistently under Solskjaer, so a Champions League quarter-final against star-studded Barca could serve as the perfect stage to jolt them from their recent slumber – rather than a fixture to fill them with fear.

A look into the annals of history of this fixture is also something the boss might have alluded to frequently in the build-up to this monumental game.

From marvellous Lionel Messi and the magic in the boots of Anthony Martial and Marcus Rashford that we hopefully will get to see on Wednesday, to Ronald Koeman’s rocket in Rotterdam and a Paul Scholes pulveriser that put the Red Devils in the 2008 final. This is a special fixture that has produced some classic encounters and memorable European nights down the years.

To think, it’s been nearly 11 years since a tense and tight two-legged semi-final tie was settled by that Scholes scorcher at Old Trafford – on a night when an emerging Messi had threatened to tear United apart single-handedly.

Of course, the two sides have met since then – twice – but over one game, in the finals of the 2009 and 2011 competition. United were good back then but perfect Barcelona were at their peak. Pep Guardiola’s side purred in an era where they had no equal.

United must evoke memories of 2008 – that Scholes goal paved the way to the final, which they won so memorably in Moscow against Chelsea. They might also look back further and to 1991 and another final – the now defunct Cup Winners’ Cup, where a Mark Hughes brace cancelled out Koeman’s fierce strike from range that crept past Les Sealey and effectively kick-started the gluttonous period of success under Sir Alex Ferguson.

Seven years earlier, Bryan Robson – who pretty much dragged insipid United through the 1980s – scored two as United overturned a 2-0 first-leg defeat to progress to the Cup Winners’ Cup semi-finals at the expense of Diego Maradona’s Barca.

A Graeme Hogg own goal and Juan Carlos Rojo’s strike looked to have been enough for the hosts in front of 94,000 at the Camp Nou, but Captain Marvel’s double and Frank Stapleton’s opener at Old Trafford sent United through – the last eight tie was their first competitive encounter with the Blaugrana.

All those involved say the cavernous atmosphere – United’s home support was revered throughout the decade – has never been repeated at Old Trafford since.

Three years later and the sides met again when paired together in the group stages of the Champions League – in then just its third season. Hughes again scored as did Lee Sharpe with a delightful back-heeled goal in a 2-2 home draw.

But United – finding their feet as a rising force under Ferguson, while the same squad they had beaten in 1991 were a year later crowned European champions – were ripped to shreds in the return game, thrashed 4-0 at the Camp Nou in a game that Hristo Stoichkov scored a brace, while Romario also found the net.

Twelve goals were shared between the teams when they were again drawn together in Group D of the 1998/99 Champions League. Both games were somehow drawn 3-3.

On matchday one, Ryan Giggs, Scholes and David Beckham scored for the hosts as Barca responded through Sonny Anderson and two penalties. What was to follow on November 25, 1998, in Catalonia, is a game considered one of the greatest in the history of the Champions League.

“It was a night of complete abandon,” Ferguson had said of the encounter. Needing to win to stay in the competition, Anderson gave the hosts a first-minute lead but Andy Cole and Dwight Yorke became almost one player as they combined to put United 3-1 ahead – their telepathy for Cole to make it 2-1 was Barcelona-esque.

Messi was the catalyst as Barca - at their peak - beat United in both the 2009 and 2011 Champions League finals.

Messi was the catalyst as Barca – at their peak – beat United in both the 2009 and 2011 Champions League finals.

Rivaldo’s stunning brace earned a point but United qualified second behind Bayern Munich who, of course, they would go on to beat in such dramatic circumstances on the same pitch six months later.

A decade after the treble, it was Scholes’ stunner that sent United into the final once more, but Barca – and Messi, the only survivor from that side still wearing the famous claret and blue shirt today – would have their revenge in Rome and London in 2009 and 2011.

Just like during those halcyon days under Guardiola, Barca remain one of football’s true forces. And while they might not be quite as good as that time, they still have Messi, who is as brilliant as he’s ever been.

So, the odds are stacked against United. But they have plenty of history to fall back on. And, under Solskajer, they are finally playing football akin to the club’s great traditions. And something approaching the swashbuckling brand of Ferguson’s heyday when they regularly graced the latter stages in Europe. So there is hope.

In an era where they are no longer among the elite, perhaps they can delve into their past and summon something extraordinary.

Most popular

'I will listen to Man United but also to other clubs' says Ander Herrera as contract negotiations stall

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
Ander Herrera has become a fan favourite at Manchester United.

Ander Herrera has spoken publicly for the first time regarding his ongoing contract standoff with Manchester United.

The midfielder could leave the club this summer on a free transfer despite having become a fan favourite since arriving at Old Trafford in 2014, making close to 200 appearances for the Red Devils.

There has been increasing speculation of a move to Paris Saint-Germain, while Arsenal are also thought to be interested in the Spaniard.

Herrera has previously been discussed as a potential United captain and has worn his heart on his sleeve regarding his love for the club, but admits negotiations over a contract extension have stalled.

“It’s true that I only have two months on my contract left and, today, Manchester [United] and I aren’t thinking the same and there is no renewal agreement, but my duty is to keep listening to United,” Herrera told ABC.

“What I have clear is that I’m going to continue playing in a big team.

“I take care of myself, I work hard and I want to squeeze as much out of football for as long as my body allows me to, because the day after I retire I will start to regret having retired.

“I will listen to United, of course, but also to other clubs. I do not close any doors.”

For the very latest news, analysis and opinion download the Sport360 app

Most popular

Related Tags