It’s time to sort out the international eligibility roulette once and for all
Eligibility, which country you play for and when, has been a hot topic this year in both rugby codes.
The issue became a real talking point several weeks back with the defection of eight New Zealand players, including their star Jason Taumalolo, and one Australian, to play for Tonga in the Rugby League World Cup (RLWC).
In Taumalolo’s case the defection bordered on the farcical as just a week previously he had appeared at a RLWC media event representing New Zealand. You can expect quite a bit of spice on November 11 in Hamilton when Taumalolo faces his old team-mates.
Eligibility of a different kind has now split the Rugby Union world with Wales suddenly changing their rules and British and Irish Lions scrum-half Rhys Webb finding himself on the outer after his decision to sign with Toulon next season.
Previously the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) had allowed coach Warren Gatland four ‘wildcard’ picks of players playing outside Wales for his national side. But they now have adopted a rule the Australian Rugby Union brought in a few years ago saying only foreign-based players who have played 60 Tests are eligible for selection.
Webb has only played 28 Tests so he is now ineligible for the team although the rule only changed after he signed for the French club.
Meanwhile, in football, to further highlight the issue – FIFA have now weighed in by suggesting they may relax their own strict eligibility rules.
Football had its own problems back in July when French Guiana were fined and forced to forfeit a match after ex-France mid-fielder Florent Malouda played for them in the CONCACAF Gold Cup.
Malouda was born in Cayenne in French Guiana, hence they had no problem selecting him for their representative team, and since French Guiana are not members of FIFA there was no issue with him playing for them previously in friendly matches.
It was only because the Gold Cup was played under FIFA eligibility rules that suddenly Malouda was illegal.
Now FIFA are considering changing their rules to help teams like French Guiana in future.
“There are so many issues that have popped up over the years because the world is changing, immigration is changing,” said Victor Montagliani, president of CONCACAF.
“There are nationality issues that pop up all over the world, in Africa, there are issues in Asia and CONCACAF, so its a good time to have a look at this and see if there are solutions, without hurting the integrity of the game.”
At present in football, players who have played a competitive international for one team cannot switch to another nation even when they hold dual nationality.
Cape Verde have proposed this rule be relaxed in cases where the player has played only one or two games for his original national side but has no realistic chance of a recall.
FIFA could also look into a compensation scheme in cases where a player goes through the training system of one country and represents it a youth level before switching to another.
Rugby now follows a similar line to football where if a player represents one country at senior level they can not play for another.
This is very harsh on the island nations such as Tonga, Samoa and Fiji who consistently lose players to ‘bigger’ rugby countries like Australia and New Zealand, although the players are often discarded after a few tests, like Taqele Naiyaravoro or Radike Samo.
League follows an overly flexible route where players can simply nominate before a tournament which nation to play for under birth, heritage or residency criteria, which leads to situations like Taumalolo.
On one side you want an even playing field with nations being as strong as possible and smaller countries not being pillaged by the larger ones, but on the other hand if a player changes nations like they change clubs it can make international tournaments untenable.
A delicate balance needs to be struck in international tournaments between integrity and competitiveness and FIFA’s suggested changes may well be the way towards reaching that.
Abu Dhabi Harlequins begin a new era without inspirational captain Ben Bolger tomorrow night when they host Dubai Hurricanes – but the players insist they must move on.
Quins will be looking to maintain their unbeaten start to the season – but the underlying current to this encounter will be the hosts heading into battle for the first time without captain courageous Bolger, who announced his retirement from rugby earlier this week.
The flanker broke the news to teammates at training on Monday, having come to the decision to call it a day with his health in mind, having suffered numerous concussions throughout his career.
Winger Chris Marshall has a particularly close bond with Bolger as they both arrived in the UAE and the club at the same time as each other. Marshall, who like Bolger has represented the UAE, at sevens level, has endured his own injury nightmare, having spent the last two years on the sidelines following a dislocated shoulder.
And even though he knows Bolger’s loss will leave a huge void, he is confident Quins will react positively.
“The team are fired up for this one after a couple of weeks off and being back at home,” said Marshall.
“Obviously it’s huge to lose someone like Ben from the side, he’s a massive part of the club both on and off the field and the boys have always looked to him as a leader.
“We arrived at the Quins at the same time so it’s gutting for me to see him hang his boots up, but I very much understand the reasoning.
“I don’t think he or the team will let it make a difference at the weekend though, we have several boys who can step up and lead from the front and Ben will very much remain a big part of the group.”
Luke Stevenson has had a similarly talismanic effect on Quins as Bolger and he too is focusing on the fact both the club and player will move on.
“It will definitely will be a factor without Ben, he’s a massive influence on all the boys on the pitch and as a bloke, not just in his performance as a player, so he will of course be missed,” said the fly-half, who featured alongside his now ex-skipper at international level for the UAE in May.
“But we’ve got boys who now get a chance to step up and I’m confident they’ll do that. He’ll still be there in the sheds before and after the game, so he’ll still have his influence. Hopefully we can put in a good performance for him.”
Canes coach, Mike Wernham, meanwhile is relishing the challenge of heading into the lion’s den to face an animal that, although unbeaten after two games, will be wounded by the loss of Bolger.
“We know it’s our biggest challenge yet, we’re under no illusions about that,” said Wernham.
“We have to raise our effort two-fold. We’re targeting certain areas after addressing what wasn’t good against Eagles. We thought the set-piece was a lot better but continuity wasn’t as strong as what it will need to be against Quins.
“We haven’t had our strongest 15 out yet so this will give us a good indication of where we’re at. I’m looking forward to going down with our strongest 22.
“These are the games you put the work in for. We have a massive challenge ahead of us but we’re looking forward to it. I’ve got a good relationship with (Quins head coach) Mike McFarlane and they remain the team to beat this season.”
Abu Dhabi Harlequins and UAE rugby was dealt a body blow on Monday when it was uncovered Ben Bolger has decided to retire from playing with immediate effect for health reasons.
The talismanic Quins and UAE national team captain took the decision due to suffering numerous and increasingly frequent concussions throughout his career – the latest of which he sustained in his side’s 15-15 draw with West Asia Premiership rivals Bahrain on September 29.
Bolger, who grew up playing rugby league and featured in nearly half a century of Super League games for London Broncos, is just 28 but has taken the decision with his health and family in mind.
A true force of nature who is loved by opponents almost as much as he is by team-mates, Bolger broke the news to Quins colleagues at training on Monday night.
Bolger, a relentless, all-action workhorse of a flanker, revealed he was ruled out by team physio Pat Milton after the Bahrain incident until 2018, and took the decision with wife Vicky to call it a day.
“I’ve had concussions throughout my career. I seem to get into big collisions all the time,” said financial planner Bolger, who revealed he’s suffered as many as maybe 20 concussions in 23 years playing the game.
“It’s part of rugby but they’ve started to come a bit too frequently and my health is more important.
“I had the conversation after the Bahrain game. We get really well looked after by our physio Pat, by all the management and coaching staff. Pat and the staff said ‘you’re not playing until after Christmas’ whatever the scan says.
“So I made the decision with my wife Vicky that it was an opportunity to call it a day.”
Bolger suffered what he called a ‘minor’ concussion during Quins’ 29-29 draw with Kandy in Sri Lanka during the pre-season Western Clubs Champions League clash. He says minor even though he can’t recall the second half after he played on.
“It only takes one more knock for it to be one too many,” he added.
“It’s different if it was a dodgy hamstring but I’ve got the rest of my life ahead of me so it was the right decision to make. I can’t say the condition is getting worse but I guess the way I play has had something to do with it.
“I try to be as physical as I can every week, which probably has a lot to do with it. The fact they’re coming a bit more quickly was definitely a factor in my decision.”
Bolger is the archetypal rugby warrior in the mould of Richie McCaw, fearless yet astute. A ferocious competitor who leads by example but sees the big picture.
Since arriving in the Emirates in 2012 he’s played in five consecutive Gulf Men’s League finals at the Dubai Sevens. He lost his first two to Jebel Ali Dragons but led Quins to a hat-trick of successes in 2016. His value to the club he’s represented with distinction for five years is immeasurable, even if the man himself admits he’s nowhere near the most talented player on the team.
“I’m not necessarily the best ball carrier or the best player or have the most amazing feet,” said Bolger when asked if, in hindsight, he would have changed his combative style.
“I just try and go out on a Friday and work harder than anyone else and be physical and get through the workload. That’s the sort of player I am.
“I’m probably not the sort of player who’s the best to watch from the sidelines but that’s the value I like to think I give my team. And that’s me as a person too. So I wouldn’t change anything.
“I’ve been involved in rugby my whole life. I’ve played 23 consecutive seasons, it’s all I’ve ever known. All my best mates are rugby players and I think that will continue, wherever I go.
“Whether I move on I’ll always be involved with a club, but not being involved week in, week out, is going to be weird. There hasn’t been a game yet so I don’t suppose it’s sunk in.
“Even if I end up coaching, not being out there and experiencing the emotions of playing in a final, that’s where it will hit me the most. If the boys are successful this season, not being there to have any effect or join in will probably really hurt.”
Bolger captained the UAE during a disappointing three-loss series at the Asia Rugby Championship’s Division I earlier this year in Malaysia. That came after he led Quins to an unprecedented season of success in 2016/17 where the club fittingly won a quintuple – West Asia Premiership, UAE Premiership, Dubai Sevens, as well as West Asia Cup and Champions League.
He admits the three defeats to Malaysia, Sri Lanka and his good friend Phil Abraham’s Philippines at international level has left a slightly sour taste, but he doesn’t have many regrets having made arguably the hardest decision of his life.
“I’ve achieved a lot in five years, domestically and then I got the chance to captain the UAE,” he said.
“It leaves a sour taste that we didn’t perform to our potential in Division I this year. I would have liked to have been successful in Malaysia.
“When Niall Statham got injured in 2016 I took on the captaincy for that tournament and we won it (Division II), but it would have been nice on the 2017 tour to be successful and made an impact. It’s the only sour taste.
“After such a successful season domestically with Quins, to not go and perform when it mattered in Malaysia was disappointing, but looking back, we’ve always been in finals with Quins or won something most seasons.
“Five trophies in one season and being the captain through all of that is special. I’ve played in five Dubai Sevens finals. Lost the first two, won the last three. Then to captain the UAE, I don’t feel like I’ve left any stones unturned so I’m pretty content with how things have gone.”
Rugby offers those who play it the chance to forge special bonds, something that Bolger feels grateful that he will still get to be a part of.
“I started the season as the first team captain so I think it would be wrong to abandon the season,” Bolger said, admitting he’ll still head down to Zayed Sports City on a Friday night to get his ‘fix’.
“All my really close mates are there, it’s been such a big part of my life here. Socially it’s been my escape from work so I’ll still use that on the weekend. It will be my fix for the week, banter with the boys.”
Bolger also paid tribute to the many messages he had received from friends and rival players since news leaked out.
He added: “I’ve had a lot of messages from different clubs wishing me the best of luck and talking about how they enjoyed our battles against each other so I’d like to thank them for that. It’s a really good reflection of what UAE rugby’s about and how everyone looks after each other.”
Dragons’ Scottish scrum-half and skipper Ross Samson described Bolger as someone opponents both loved and loathed playing against in equal measure.
“I’m gutted for Benny having to retire,” said Samson. “The guy’s an animal, we love and hate playing against him. Dragons boys are thinking of him and our thoughts are with him and Quins.”
It’s the end of an era for one of UAE rugby’s most iconic figures in recent years, but Quins coach Mike McFarlane believes Bolger has made the right decision.
“It’s a huge loss for the club both on and off the pitch,” said McFarlane.
“He’s an inspiring leader, a top class player and someone who breathes the club culture. We’ve been through some battles together and couldn’t have had a better season last year and I’ve learnt a lot from him.
“As a good friend it’s the right decision and like any player at the club, their health and safety is paramount. He will still be involved, imparting his wisdom on the boys, and will continue to be an important part of the Quins make-up.”
Bolger’s news comes after Dubai Exiles winger Ed James also retired early, aged just 27, earlier this year after suffering concussion in a freak accident playing against Bahrain in January. Quins winger Chris Marshall has only returned to the first-team fold this season following two years out with a dislocated shoulder. It also evokes memories of Mike Ballard. The American broke his back and was left wheelchair-bound following an injury sustained playing against Dragons in the West Asia Champion Club final in April 2014.