RWC 2019: Scotland ratings as Ryan Wilson is woeful in convincing defeat to Ireland

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
An exasperated Stuart Hogg looks on as Ireland score a try.

Scotland slumped to a disheartening 27-3 defeat against Ireland as the Dark Blues began their Rugby World Cup under a dark cloud.

Despite having designs on the Webb Ellis Cup, and at least targeting a first-ever trip to the semi-finals, while their opponents are just concentrating on getting out of the group, Ireland were expected to be severely tested by their fellow home nation.

But it was a one-sided affair from the start as Ireland’s ferocious forwards dominated the first half, while staunch defence kept Scotland under control as they improved after the break.

James Ryan, Rory Best and Tadhg Furlong barged over for first-half scores, with Andrew Conway crossing for a bonus point try in a second half that marked by a downpour. For the Scots, a sole Greig Laidlaw penalty was a paltry return from a game expected to be much more of a contest.

Here is how we rated the Scotland players:

Allan Dell 7: Also part of the front row that tried to stem Ireland’s flow, making 12 tackles.

Stuart McInally 7: Captain led from front, or tried to. Embarked on 12 runs, only Hogg made more, and tackled like a demon (10). Looked visibly dejected.

Willem Nel 7: Ferocious on the back foot as he made 16 tackles – not missing one. No-one came close.

Grant Gilchrist 3: Two missed tackles and conceded a turnover, not a good day at the office.

Jonny Gray 6: Tackling machine, making 11/11, and the go-to man in the lineout. Beat a man but fell foul of impressive Irish pack.

John Barclay 4: Dropped the ball as Scotland had finally made inroads into Ireland and were camped in the shadow of their posts. Edinburgh No8 has had better games.

Hamish Watson 5: Lost to a serious leg injury. Appeared in tears as he was wheeled off for what looks likely his first and last involvement at the World Cup.

Ryan Wilson 3: Dropped a high punt as conditions worsened. It got worse for Wilson as Ireland scored from it. Three handling errors in total. Woeful.

Greig Laidlaw 4: Visibly frustrated as he tried to cajole his team-mates. Booted side’s only points. Made significantly more passes (64) than anyone else, but offered little.

Finn Russell 5: Did well to deliver pass to Maitland – that led to penalty – before being obliterated by Aki. Tried his best to spark a suffocated Scotland attack, came to life and showed flashes of brilliance in second half.

Sean Maitland 7: Always looked one of the players most likely to deliver. Good driving run to start second half. Made second most metres (49), but missed two of three tackles.

Sam Johnson 5: Try-saving tackle on Stockdale in first half, otherwise it would have been game over after 30 minutes. Frustrated going forward.

Duncan Taylor 7: Difficult to judge as he made errors but showed more heart than anyone else. Excellent rip at ruck showed he was up for the fight. Always looked to carry, let down once by a knock on, one of three turnovers. Ten tackles.

Tommy Seymour 4: Anonymous, despite making third most metres (25) via three runs and beating one defender. Overawed.

Stuart Hogg 7: Had pace to beat Conway easily, won a turnover to alleviate pressure. Always darting around trying to spark the Scots, no other player on the field made more runs (16).

SUBS:

Fraser Brown 6: Where was he for Conway’s try? Left blindside open as winger strolled over.

Darcy Graham 6: Livewire was thrown on to inject some life into his side, but it was too late.

Blade Thomson 6: New Zealand-born utility man got going with five carries and weighed in with seven tackles, missing none.

Simon Berghan 6: Two turnovers conceded in his 28 minutes on the pitch.

Recommended

Most popular

RWC 2019: CJ Stander stands tall while Jordan Larmour is a livewire as Ireland squash Scotland

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
CJ Stander was immense for Ireland.

Ireland swept Scotland aside to start their 2019 Rugby World Cup in fine style, the Men in Green marching to a dominant 27-3 win in Yokohama.

Despite having designs on the Webb Ellis Cup, and at least targeting a first-ever trip to the semi-finals with their opponents are just concentrating on getting out of the group, Ireland were expected to be severely tested by their fellow home nation.

But it was a one-sided affair from the start as Ireland’s ferocious forwards dominated the first half, while staunch Irish defence kept the Dark Blues as they improved after the break.

The front five in-particular were on fire as James Ryan, Rory Best and Tadhg Furlong barged over for first-half scores, with Andrew Conway crossing for a bonus point try in a second half that marked by a downpour.

Here is how we rated the Ireland players:

Cian Healy 7: Came into World Cup with injury cloud over head. A souped up terrier for the 50 minutes he was on the field.

Rory Best 7: How did he ground the ball while lying on his back and on top of a pile of bodies? Superb awareness from the skipper to start his Irish swansong.  Missed just one tackle.

Tadhg Furlong 7: Bulldog prop bulldozed over as Ireland’s forwards ran riot. Scotland could not keep a leash on him, making nine tackles.

Iain Henderson 7: Ryan may be the poster boy but it was his lock partner’s barnstorming run that set up the opening score. Forced a turnover too on a busy afternoon.

James Ryan 8: Capped meteoric rise with try on World Cup debut. Giant lock was a handful throughout, carrying ball a team joint high 15 times and also joint leading Ireland with 14 tackles.

Peter O’Mahony 6: Stalwart only played 26 minutes as he was replaced following Furlong’s try. Ireland will sweat over his fitness.

Josh Van Der Flier 6: Completed 100 per cent of his 10 tackles but made only two metres. Game disrupted by injury.

CJ Stander 9: Burst into space looking for bonus point score inside 30 minutes, but no support. Kept driving holes through Scotland. Made third most metres in green and joint most runs.

Conor Murray 6: Sharp and alert from the off, passing was crisp. Took on kicking duties from half-back partner Sexton, knocking over one conversion but missing a penalty. Faded.

Johnny Sexton 5: Missed wide conversion, Murray took over, which could indicate an issue. Strangely on the periphery as forwards dominated.

Jacob Stockdale 6: Formidable forwards led the way, but his cute chip and chase almost led to a score. Immense tackle on Stuart Hogg as Scotland pressed for late try.

Bundee Aki 6: Tenacious, superb steal to set up early chance. Couple of brutish runs early on but then came off as HIA ruled him out for rest of the game.

Garry Ringrose 4: Couldn’t get going as he made only nine metres going forward and three passes, missed two tackles too.Chris Farrell was far more vibrant.

Andrew Conway 7: Poor start with a knock on under little pressure. Made up for it with kick, chase and tackle on Hogg. Then got into gear with a dangerous run down right wing. Capped his rise with an easy try.

Jordan Larmour 8: Confident early take under high ball, followed by a penetrating run. Then sprung up at a ruck to win a penalty. Made 69 metres from 11 runs as he looked menacing. Will first-choice Rob Kearney get back in?

SUBS:

Jack Conan 6: Busy early as he was used to cover Van der Flier and O’Mahony injuries. Solid rather than spectacular.

Chris Farrell 8: On for the concussed Aki. Used powerful frame to batter beleaguered Scots. Beautiful behind the back offload to McGrath. Charge through almost led to fifth score. Only Larmour made more metres than his 53.

Andrew Porter 6: Came on and got involved, without shining.

Luke McGrath 6: Busy when he was introduced, a smart offload and making 11 metres.

Tadhg Beirne 3: On the field barely 10 minutes before shown a yellow for killing the ball.

Jack Carty 6: Kicked an easy penalty, lively but little chance to strut stuff.

Dave Kilcoyne 7: Four runs from replacement prop as Ireland looked to sustain stranglehold. Five tackles.

Most popular

RWC 2019: Warren Gatland reveals Wales players and staff have contacted Rob Howley

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • Mail
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • G+
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
Rob Howley (l) has been sent home from the World Cup.

Wales boss Warren Gatland says a number of players and staff have contacted Rob Howley after he was sent home from the Rugby World Cup.

Wales go into their World Cup opener against Georgia on Monday in the wake of assistant coach Howley leaving Japan for an alleged breach of World Rugby’s betting regulations.

Howley, 48, has returned to Wales to assist with an investigation.

Gatland said: “Alun Wyn (Jones, the Wales captain) made a good comment to everyone – these things happen, you lose players, the wheel keeps turning and you have to move on.

“It’s been tough, but you have to draw a line in the sand and concentrate on what your job and your role is.

“A number of players and staff have reached out to Rob. The biggest thing we can do is offer him as much support as we can.

“We can’t change what has happened, but it is important we do provide support.

“There are a lot of good people out there who have reached out to offer him support. That is pleasing.

“We can’t change what has happened. We have to really focus on the next couple of days and hopefully things go well on Monday (against Georgia), and then we build up to Australia.”

Howley’s coaching replacement – former Wales fly-half Stephen Jones – took part in his first training session on Saturday, and Gatland is delighted with how ready his players are to launch what will be a final World Cup for him as head coach.

“There was a little bit of edge and niggle at training (on Saturday). To me, that’s always a good sign. The players know the game is coming close,” he added.

“I said to the players after training, ‘we’ve had our warm-up games – we’re in competition phase now, and that’s when we thrive’.

“We are Grand Slam champions, had 14 games in a row unbeaten and that was because of the way we prepared, mentally how tough we were, our game management, and I thought today there was that edge.

“We know that when we prepare well and train well and everything is right, we’re a tough team to beat and can beat anyone.

“We’ve worked incredibly hard to get to where we are and achieve what we’ve achieved in the last few years, and we need to make sure we go out and give our best at this World Cup.”

Such is Wales’ strength in depth that 34-cap number eight Ross Moriarty has to be content with a place on the bench, covering a back row comprising 21-year-old World Cup debutant Aaron Wainwright, Justin Tipuric and Josh Navidi.

“He (Moriarty) is not too happy with me with him not being in the side, but I have to say that from the initial disappointment and the chat we had, he’s turned that around,” Gatland said.

“He’s been positive, vocal at training and he’s been what you expect of someone who knows they are disappointed but also knows what their role is in the team, which is to help the side prepare. That’s all I can ask as a coach.”

Most popular